There is no funnel cake in the International Media Circus

by Sweeney on December 1, 2011

My phone rings and I know it’s my mom – she’s the only one who has my house phone. Well, her and the automated French recording that calls every so often.

“Derrik was arrested in Cairo.”

“Wait, what!?

It was a short phone call – she wanted to make sure that I heard it from her. My cousin was watching the news and three boys appeared. Two were named, the third was identified only as a Georgetown student, but she recognized him right away and called my mom.

A mental image that is likely to haunt me for some time.

As soon as I hung up, my first response was to take to the internet. I asked Google for “americans arrested cairo.” A flurry of news stories popped up. Step two: turn to HootSuite and add a feed for “Derrik Sweeney” and “derriksweeney.” Minutes later I watched the tweet roll in that first IDed the third student – my brother.

During this time I called my dad and there was some uncertainty as to how we should respond. Should we call Georgetown – see if anyone there can help? Should we start alerting the media? Will we be getting him in more trouble? It didn’t occur to me just how intense the media frenzy would become.

Then I saw a tweet alerting Barbara Boxer that her constituent was in need of her assistance.

Oh. All right. Well now we’re playing with something I understand.” I corrected that tweet – he’s a Missouri resident – and sent some out to both of our Senators and our representative. Within minutes the media emails commenced. There was the initial hesitation – how should we respond to this?

My feeling, the reason I chose the just-keep-talking route, was that there was a real possibility that he could just sort of disappear. It seemed our best ally was the combination of the always-on media and the political pressure that Egypt has to keep getting a ridiculous check from the American government.

Things from his Facebook appeared in news stories within the hour of his name being made public. Given how little we knew at that point, this seemed like a problem. How many stories are there of people being incriminated less by facts than by the character witness represented in their social media profiles? Derrik’s roommates pointed this out to me and I spent about 45 minutes trying to get it taken down.

Blogger friends suggested flagging his profile – which they, and some of Derrik’s friends, did. I don’t know how long that would have taken; I managed to get in first. Don’t keep a Hotmail account connected to your Facebook. True, there is a sidebar to this story (involving my internet-media-producing-11-year-old self and AOL’s spam policy) that makes this an unfair indictment on Hotmail’s security, but it wasn’t all that difficult for me to convince Hotmail that I was Derrik.

My first interview was a terrifying over-the-phone with CNN. I wasn’t sure which was the greater danger: that I would start sobbing or that I would vomit. My blogger friends started posting the CNN story all over Facebook and started a hashtag on Twitter. (Although, real talk, #BringDerrikSweeneyHome is a really long hashtag. And nobody got the odd spelling on his name right.) The 20sb admin team even put up a post on my behalf. I cannot say enough how much I appreciate all of the support during that terrifying week.

The media circus was unrelenting. Calls home were frequent but always short; my parents were dealing with the press calls and the cameras. In addition to the “What is going to happen to him?” agony there was the stress of ever-changing information. If I mapped it out, the developments were mostly positive, but every two steps forward were accompanied by another step and a half backwards.

My mom on CNN

My mom on CNN.

There was just so much ambiguity, so many things we didn’t know. Yet we were being asked endless questions in the middle of that anxiety and mis-information. My parents said some things that they’d like to take back, but I understand the place those comments came from.

I understand the fear and the feeling that all you want to do is see this kid and give him a hug and OH LOOK, here is a person who wants to talk to me about him and I feel like my entire world is exploding but maybe if I just keep talking to you I can keep it together so that’s fine I’ll just. keep. talking.

It’s kind of like that. Word vomit is inevitable.

One of the harder pills to swallow was watching everyone develop an opinion on my family. I blog about my life. I am pretty “out there.” But I walk a fine line when it comes to the other “characters” in my life; even when I give them aliases, it doesn’t give me free reign over their stories or the ways in which I represent them. Putting my shit out there is a choice that I made, and that doesn’t give me the right to impose it on everyone around me.

Because this is my blog, I’ll come out and say it: it seems to me that they were arrested for the sole purpose of being paraded about Egyptian television in order to convince people that this wasn’t their cause — that Americans were instigating this (violently, no less). There’s a certain irony to that portrait when you consider the actual relationship between the American government and Egyptian politics, but things like facts weren’t really important here.

Cue reactions back home, falling mostly into two camps: “Serves ‘em right for leaving the USA! ‘MERICA’S THE GREATEST. ISOLATIONISM IS AWESOME.” -and- “War mongering Republicans throwing bombs in the Middle East! Let them hang!” I can’t say I found it surprising that few people seemed to entertain the idea that the claims of the Egyptian authorities were bullshit. Unfortunate, sure, but not surprising.

I felt the reality of my family’s newfound out-there-ness during class on Monday night. My professor pointed out questions he felt journalists should have been asking of Derrik – how is it that he got arrested when there are plenty of other Americans in Cairo right now who aren’t?

I was in an awful mood for the next day or two (this is part of why I didn’t know what to write about all of this sooner) until I finally realized what was bothering me: I was furious. Last week I was consumed by an oppressive sense of fear. Fear and anxiety trumped all other emotions. When he was released, I had a couple days of incredible gratitude and happiness.

ridiculouslygrateful tweets

I got a little excited on Twitter. Just a little.

After that I was brought back to the emotion that underpinned the entire week – anger. One of the most basic rules of sibling relationships is that I can say whatever I want about my siblings, but I will obviously have to fight you if you say anything about them. Over the course of a week, I watched as half the world was given license to berate my little brother. That’s a lot of people to want to fight all at once. I can handle myself, sure, but…

It doesn’t matter that nothing the Egyptian authorities said was true – down to the very location where they were arrested. It doesn’t matter that their backpacks had been brought to Tahrir filled with medical supplies for the makeshift hospital areas set up to care for protesters wounded by the very violent police. It doesn’t matter that arresting them made for very convenient propaganda. None of that is important to the mobs of angry comment trolls who saw his face – his terrified face – set behind a caption about molotov cocktails.

The thing is, none of that matters all that much to me either. For me, there is one basic fact: he is my brother. My parents made some stupid comments in interviews and we have already joked about a few of them. My frustration with derisive responses to those comments doesn’t come from my feeling that they’ve been taken out of context (though I believe they have), it comes from that basic fact that they are my parents.

I’ve been putting my life on public display for a while, but to a minuscule, safe “public.” More importantly, it has been on my terms. This? What just happened? Above and beyond anything I could have prepared for.

But the lesson of last week was ultimately about perspective. On Thanksgiving, when he was ordered released, I was elated. The idea that something so simple – “Your brother is coming home.” – could afford that much happiness? Awesome.

Then there are the countless people who reached out on Facebook and Twitter to spread the word or just remind me that they were keeping my family in their thoughts. I haven’t thanked everyone individually because there are seriously too many. Having too much to be grateful for is a nice problem to have. So for that thank you. Thank you to 20sb, and everyone who tweeted at Congress members, and just everyone who guaranteed, if nothing else, that he would not be allowed to simply vanish in that system. If I’m being honest, that probably even includes the citizens of Trolldom.

Given the choice between taking the poorly articulated vitriol of a thousand avatar heads or my little brother disappearing behind the curtain of a military regime, I happily accept the former.

  • http://democracydiva.com/ Democracy Diva

    A beautiful post. 

    And in your defense, that capslock tweet made me laugh out loud. It was awesome.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      Thank you! Couldn’t get it any shorter, but I’m glad it was at least good.

      It’s on par with water and breathing for significance to my life, so it deserved my appreciation.

  • http://melbourneonmymind.com Melbourne on my mind

    As far as I’m concerned, you did exactly what you needed to do. Forget the trolls – Derrik’s home now and that’s what’s important!! We did media training in the lead up to the gallery opening, and there’s no way I could have spoken to the media about objects in showcases as calmly as you did about something so much more significant. Also, your caps lock tweets were awesome. <3

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      It’s easier now that he is home and this is all dying off, but it was really rough for a few days there.  Especially after I heard that the whole reason they had the backpacks was to bring medical supplies.  MEDICAL SUPPLIES!  I really wish I had known that when I was doing interviews and stuff.

      thank you <3

  • http://twitter.com/mrscaptkerk Shelly

    I hated reading the comments on websites, I tried not to read them but I couldn’t help it.  I loved when the truth came out.  I wanted to just point in their faces and say “Suck it Trebek!”

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      Me too!  THEY WERE NEVER ON A ROOF, THEY NEVER THREW ANYTHING, AND THE ONLY THING THEY BROUGHT IN THOSE BACKPACKS WERE MEDICAL SUPPLIES FOR PROTESTERS WOUNDED BY POLICE.  SO SIT DOWN, ASSHOLES.

      The flip side that I forgot to mention is that I developed a hardcore affinity for every commenter who stuck up for them.  I just want to be friends with all of those people.

  • http://strugglingsingletwentysomething.blogspot.com Katie

    I’m so glad this all ended well and Derrik is home and okay. I can’t imagine what a nightmare last week was for your family.

    Trolls come out in huge numbers for just about any news story, and their comments are always so black-and-white. A good friend of mine’s uncle was convicted of forgery and witness intimidation a couple of years ago and is now in prison, and when I read a news story about it, people were incredibly harsh. They didn’t know all of the good things about him that I’d heard from my friend, like what a good father he was to his kids and how he helped my friends out when they had to move out of a crappy apartment. In Derrik’s case, he hadn’t done what he was accused of, but even if someone actually has done something wrong, people need to remember that they’re talking about a person who has loved ones and that there’s always more to a story than can be portrayed in the news.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      This isn’t the first time that I’ve been somewhat close to a national story, this is just the closest  (last time it was kind of like your situation in terms of degrees of separation) so I really did know better than to read the comments on the stories but it’s so hard to stop yourself.

      For the most part, I still do adhere to the basic idea that being in the public eye grants the public the right to comment on you and your actions, but it is frustrating as all hell.  Especially since they didn’t really do anything wrong, other than be obviously foreign in the wrong place.  Regardless, it puts a whole new perspective on that idea of commenting on public figures.  Like you said, there is always more to the story and there are always people close to this person who feel the sting of it too.  It wasn’t all bad, though — as much as I hated the people berating them in comments, I pretty much fell in love with every single person who came to their defense and want to be friends with all of them.

  • http://www.anywhere-but-home.com Naomi

    Your family has my support. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with what your brother did, and I’m glad that he’s home safe :)

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      Thank you <3

  • http://shtoshouwhat.wordpress.com/ Christina

    This is so well said and I absolutely love your last line. I can’t even imagine what you had to go through and how difficult it must have been, but I think you should be given so much credit for handling it the way you did.

    I feel like there are always those times where we blame the internet and social media for all the negative things it causes, but then looking at it in retrospect, it’s also pretty amazing that it gives us such a great outlet, especially when it’s needed in time like these.

    I’ve been following the events in Egypt and only later put the two together… I don’t think I got a chance to say anything, but I’m so glad it’s all over now and that your brother is safe!

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      Ha! Everyone keeps saying that, but that’s only because I spent the better part of last week locked in my apartment so nobody actually SAW the sobbing, nauseous wreck that I was. But, yeah.. I WAS TOTALLY TAKING IT LIKE A CHAMP.  Or something like that.

      Agreed – you’re always missing a big part of the picture when you resort to blanket techno-pessimism or techno-optimism.  The implications of all of this technology are vast, far-reaching, and complicated.  It’s great to be able to see how awesome it can be, though.

      Thank you!

  • http://pst-mod-talko.blogspot.com Erin Mc Awesome

    When I first saw the video I cried for your brother and you because there he was so scared and alone and he didn’t know you were doing everything you could for him and you had to deal with that.

    (Gross, I’m tearing up as I write this) 
    Dood, you’re a social media monster and your crisis mode skills were onomonopia-ing the crap out of that situation.  You can have my avatar’s sword, any day. 

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      That was part of what I found so horrifying at first — the fact that he had no way of knowing that we were aware.  He said that getting that first visit from the Embassy official was seriously spirit lifting because it reassured him that, if nothing else, they weren’t likely to be executed there.  He wasn’t particularly sure, up until they were actually released, how long he might be held, but the terror became for his future rather than his life itself.

      A mighty sword it is, Erin.  Thank you. ;)

  • http://thelatepartygirls.com Lorraine

    I kept reading the troll comments too. And honestly all I wanted to do was yell about them, but I knew that would’ve be helpful. I didn’t know if you were seeing them, and I didn’t want to draw your attention.

    People. suck. Seriously. I understand that I was personally invested, but there were just some things said that I wouldn’t wish upon my worst enemy. Or even my worst fictional enemy, Jessica Wakefield. Okay, wait, maybe her.

    Anyways the point is that you did so well in the face of all this. I would’ve cried on CNN. For sure, for sure.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      It was so hard to just not say anything, but they’re like bug infestations — you squash one and dozens more appear.

      Thank you <3

  • http://www.suburbansweetheart.com/ Suburban Sweetheart

    Holy. Crap. What a time I chose to discover your blog – and what a post. This is… God, I don’t even know what this is. I’m so sorry this happened, that your brother went through this, that your family was assaulted by the media, that the world thinks it’s their place to berate your brother for something they know nothing about. Kudos to you for doing some emergency maintenance, like of the Facebook profile, etc., to do all you could do use social media to help instead of hurt your brother. I’m so, so glad to hear that he’s safe.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      It was a whole lot of crazy, but he’s home and I guess all is well that ends well.  Thank you :)

  • http://woodycakes.livejournal.com Patty

    *HUGS* i didn’t realize it was this crazy and I”m sorry I wasn’t able to be there for you.
    Social media, who knew, right? i’m glad things are okay. Still keeping your family in my thoughts.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      Love you lots. I got your postcard the other day! I am using this belated comment reply to say thank you :-)

      • http://woodycakes.livejournal.com Patty

        i’m glad :) i hope your 2012 is awesome so far!

  • Nagehan

    I agree that we take a lot of things for granted and it only takes moments like this to realize that we have a lot to be thankful for in life.

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      So very true. I feel like you can never really be too thankful.

  • Pingback: Blogging about blogging, caffeine, and being a bad friend. — Sweeney Says...

  • Pingback: The church van road trip and a year in review — Sweeney Says...

  • http://womeneverywhere.wordpress.com/ Melissa

    This is a super interesting post. I have to admit, I kind of believed the story about what they were doing. After all, I’ve studied abroad and I’ve seen some Americans do really, really stupid things while they were abroad – so I didn’t put it past them, I have to say sadly of my own people. But I do have to say that reading your post has helped me to see this from a different angle and to perhaps consider that what I heard wasn’t true (something I do often enough but given the right scenario, even I will forget to do). So thank you. I’m sorry for what happened to your brother, but I’m glad that he made it home  safe. 

    • http://www.sweeneysays.com Sweeney

      I didn’t really articulate it in this post because it was more about the protectiveness it made me feel, but as frustrated as I was, I also could not help but understand how this looked to anyone on the outside. This is the way media works and all I can really do is try to take the whole thing to heart when I hear things on the news in the future…and I have seen more than my share of stupidity from study abroad students so I totally know what you mean.

      But thank you :-) Good will from unexpected places has been one of the best parts of this whole ordeal.

Previous post:

Next post: